Terre Pruitt's Blog

In the realm of health, wellness, fitness, and the like, or whatever inspires me.

  • I teach Nia, yoga and stretch! SIX group classes a week!

    Nia: Tues and Thurs at 9 am, Fri at 10:15 am

    Yoga: Tues at 10:30 am and Thurs at 6:00 pm

    Stretch: Thurs at 10:15 am

    Please see my website for details! I sub for the City of San Jose and the YMCA so check my website for dates and times!

    I am also available for private Nia / yoga / Personal Training!

  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

  • My Bloggey Past

  • ******

    Chose a month above to visit archives, or click below to visit a page.

Another Zumba and Nia Comparison

Posted by terrepruitt on June 30, 2012

I teach Nia.  I have been teaching Nia for three and a half years.  Not as many people who I talk to have heard of Nia as have heard of Zumba so I am constantly being asked the difference between Nia and Zumba. Since I am often asked I am often thinking about them and comparing them. First, they are actually the same in that music is played and participants dance to it.  Second, in both the instructor leads the participants through the various dance moves.  Third, participants of both claim they are both fun. One difference is Nia is an experience in five sensations, Zumba seems to concentrate on one.

The experience is such a big part of Nia we actually call them the five sensations of Nia.  I have posted about them before (FAMSS).  They are the sensation of flexibility, of agility, of mobility, of strength, and of stability.  In a Nia class your body will move in a way that allows you to sense the energy moving out and away.  You will bend and stretch to play with flexibility, either retaining what you have or improving upon it.  There are moves in the routines that require the start and the stop.  The movement that is agility could be done with our feet, our arms, our hands, our bodies, our heads or a combination of body parts but we sense the start and the stop.  With every routine there is a lot of mobility, some routines have more than others, but all of them that I have experienced have a lot.  With mobility it is just the same as agility in that it could be a body part that is moving or our whole body.  Whatever the case there is a lot of movement from each joint that helps create a healthy joint by allowing the fluid to move to it and within it.  Then we also play with strength.  We might squeeze our muscles sensing the energy moving in as if the bones are being hugged by the muscles.  We might do squats or sit-ups, punches and/or kicks, but there is time where we play with strength.  I say Nia is very big on balance because we do many moves that requires us to be stable.  Many of our moves are balancing on one leg, could be a kick, could be a stance, but it requires stability.  Moving from one move to the next often requires us to call upon our stability.  In a Nia routine we experience all of these sensations.  I’ve reached the conclusion that Zumba is primarily agility.

In Zumba the moves are always fast.  So it is a constant state of start and stop.  The only sensation I sense while doing Zumba is agility.  Fast start, fast stop . . . .  even when there is a stretch where your muscles are yearning for a second to move to their fullest length, it is a fast stretch that does not allow for the muscle to be fully stretched.  Doing a full hour of agility is not a bad thing at all.  It can be fun and it can produce a lot of sweat.  And many of us are programmed to think that sweat equals a good workout.  I think that if you are adding Zumba to a stretching program that has some balance practice in it that is great.

I am also a believer that there are a lot of things that compliment Nia too.  I actually think that if you like Nia and Zumba and you are able to do both that is a nice combination.  You get two different types of cardio.  One that is a workout in the sensation of agility and one that can move you through more use of the entire body to get that heart pumping.

I really believe that whatever gets you moving is GREAT.  I think that you have to like what you do in order to make it a constant in your life.  So Zumba, Nia, Jazzercise, U-Jam, yoga, kickboxing, bootcamp, weight training, whatever works for you is great.  Do what you will do!  That is the key!

It is that I am always asked about the difference between Zumba and Nia that I am always thinking about it and this was my latest thought after I did a Zumba class.  I think I posted before about how I am left wanting to extend and finish my moves in Zumba and it dawned on me that it is the sensation of agility that is predominant in Zumba.  Some Zumba classes I have attended do take a song to stretch at the end, but not all of them.  So I guess it depends on the instructor.  Nia instructors are encouraged to infuse their classes and the routines with their personalities, so I am sure that every Nia class has a few differences too.

Both Nia and Zumba are great cardio workouts.  It just depends on what you want to do during your workout and what you want to get out of it.  Do what you will do!

So, what is it that you do? 

11 Responses to “Another Zumba and Nia Comparison”

  1. I need to try Nia to compare! Zumba to me is alternating high and low impact routines. I love it, but it requires a lot of sweat! My teacher does a lot of hip-hop and DOES do a stretch song at the end. But she is not typical. She is more like the kind of instructor you can wear your belly scarf jingle skirt to class. 🙂

    Like

    • I do hope you get to a Nia class one day. The main website (NiaNow.com) shows classes in Irving and Fort Worth. I know you would love it because you can just dance YOUR heart out. Nia doesn’t require sweat, but we sure get sweaty. Everyone gets out of it what they put in. Some of my students are on their way to work so they don’t get as sweaty on purpose!

      You must enjoy your teacher or you wouldn’t be there. That is important too. I should have stated that in my post. I have stated it before though. I think a teacher should be giving at least THREE chances. And if you don’t like one teacher try another–if you don’t like “it” (whatever the class it) it could just be the teacher so give it another change.

      I love that you are Zumba-ing. I am sure you wear your belly dance garb to class, huh?

      Like

  2. I am now a proud White Belt taken for my own pleasure. I am doing R1 everyday by DVD. I was googling the difference between Nia and Zumba calories burned per hour?
    What I say is that Zumba is more masculine with sharp movements while Nia is more feminine with more flowing movements. Enjoyed you blog. Where are you? I’m in Arizona about 125 miles from Ticson. I also go to Anna Maria Island, Flirida and dance with Gail Condrick and Kathy Orvick. Irene

    Like

  3. niachick said

    I teach Nia and in my humble, but professional opinion, there is NOTHING like Nia. The two points you covered — there is music and people dance; there is an instructor who leads the class — are the ONLY similarities. I’ve taught Zumba. It is too high impact for me and I get bored with the Latin music. However, I know ALOT of folks who enjoy Zumba, so bravo that they are finding something that works for them. I sweat in Nia and so do my students. I use a variety of music and there is a plethora of movements that can be choreographically arranged to be different in every class. So in my 62nd year on earth, and in my 12th year of teaching Nia, my claim on the “energy” of both Nia and Zumba is that Nia is a long lasting relationship and Zumba is a one-night stand. Both are lots of fun. Nia is by design less likely to cause injury (I reinjured my knee doing Zumba a couple of years ago). I reinjured my knee just a few weeks ago, but not from Nia. Nia is actually helping me strengthen it, making the sensations of flexibility, agility, mobility and stability easier to manage. Thanks, as always for your blogs!!! Love ’em!!!

    Like

Let me hear it. What have you got to say about this post?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: